I'm Brandon Wigley, and I make the cases marked "ours" below. This comparison is built from each maker's own listing and the retailers named; it is not a set of reviews. No link here is an affiliate link, and the only thing we sell is our own case.
You can buy Hunt A Killer cases one at a time now. Its Blood & Ink box is $29.99, and the recurring plan it now sells is an optional membership, Evidence Locker, at $50 a year for early access, free shipping and extra rewards points; the cases are still bought individually. So the old reason to look elsewhere, a box billed every month, mostly isn't the reason anymore.
The reasons that are left are practical ones: a different price, a shorter or longer evening, a case you can start tonight without waiting for the mail, or simply more cases once you've worked through theirs. The ten below cover those, from mailed evidence files to a printable PDF to a free case in your browser.
Hunt A Killer and Ten Alternatives at a Glance
Prices are for the editions and sellers named. We checked the listings on November 22, 2026. Sale prices, stock and shipping change.
| Game or edition | What you get | Format and internet | Players | Age | Time | Price and terms |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hunt A Killer: Blood & Ink (the benchmark) | One standalone case | Mailed box; some cases add an online part | 1 to 6 | 14+ | 90 to 120 min | $29.99 once. Optional Evidence Locker membership, $50 a year |
| Unsolved Case Files: Harmony Ashcroft | One case | Printed folder; answers are checked online | 1 or more | 14+ | About 2 to 3 hours | $16.99 at Target and on Amazon, where the maker sells it (regular price $19.99). A separate US subscription exists |
| University Games: Death by Chef's Knife | One case | Printed evidence file; hints and solution online | 1 or more | 14+ | 45 to 60 min (Target) | $17.49 at Target |
| Deadbolt Mystery Society | One standalone box | Mailed evidence, plus online clues by QR code | 1 to 4 | 13+ | Typically 2 to 3 hours | One-time shop: The Christmas Light Caper $24.99 on sale (regular $28.99, pre-order); a four-box bundle $65.99. A separate membership is regularly $34.99 a month |
| Cryptic Killers: Murder of a Millionaire | One case | Mailed evidence, plus an online police inbox | 1 to 10 | 13+ (Amazon listing) | About 2 hours | $19.99 on Amazon.com, sold by LA Brands. The maker's UK shop: £14.99 on sale |
| Masters of Mystery: The Murder of Edward Munst | One case | Boxed evidence or digital documents, with an online case portal | Solo or two | Not stated | About 1 to 2 hours | $25 digital on the maker's site; the boxed kit is listed only in pounds, at £24.99 |
| Ink & Clues: The Girl in the Snow | One case, or a bundle of eight and a bonus | Instant PDF, to print or read on screen | 1 to 6 | 18+ for this case | 1.5 to 2 hours | $14 for the case; $67 for the bundle on sale (regular $111) |
| Cold Ledger cold cases (ours) | One case | Printable PDF or in the browser, instantly | 1 or 2 | 16+ for three cases, 12+ for one | 60 to 90 min | Regularly $6.99 a case |
| CaseZero | First case free; three more in Case Pack 01 | Browser | Solo play described | 16+ to buy or sign up | 30 to 90 min a case | Free to start. €12.99 once for the pack |
| PLAY INQUEST | A free daily case; optional Premium | Browser; a free account adds two-player co-op | 1 or 2 | Teens and adults | A short daily; longer cases | Free. Premium $3 a month or $3.50 once for 30 days with the current checkout discount (regular price $5) |
| Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases | Ten cases in one box | A London map, a directory, newspapers and case books; no internet | 1 to 8 | 14+ (Space Cowboys) or 12+ (Asmodee USA) | About 90 min a case | $59.99 listed by Asmodee USA |
Mailed Case Files
Unsolved Case Files: Harmony Ashcroft. You work through three objectives using documents and photographs, and you check each answer online to learn when to open the next bonus envelope. The maker's own site sends you to retailers; Target and Amazon, where the maker sells it directly, both listed the case at $16.99. The maker also sells a separate subscription in the US, so read which one you are buying.
Death by Chef's Knife, from University Games, is a single evidence file about the death of a New York chef: photographs, a newspaper, a postcard and dozens of other pieces, with hints and the full solution online. University Games recommends it for ages 14 and up, alone or with a group, and Target listed it at $17.49.
Deadbolt Mystery Society sells standalone boxes from its one-time shop, apart from its monthly membership. Each mystery combines physical evidence with online clues you reach by scanning QR codes, so bring a phone or laptop to the table. Its one-time shop listed one single box, The Christmas Light Caper, at $24.99 on sale (regular $28.99), and a four-box bundle at $65.99.
Cryptic Killers: Murder of a Millionaire gives you 29 pieces of physical evidence and an online police inbox to investigate. The maker suggests about two hours. It is a UK maker whose own shop prices in pounds; in the US it sells on Amazon, where it listed at $19.99.
Masters of Mystery: The Murder of Edward Munst is a cold case for one or two people: statements, photographs and reports, in a printed kit or as digital documents, with an online portal either way. From the US, the maker's site showed $25 for the digital edition; the boxed kit was listed only in pounds, at £24.99.
Cases You Can Start Tonight
Ink & Clues: The Girl in the Snow is a 40-page case file you download and print, or read on a screen, for one to six people. The maker recommends this case for ages 18 and up because of graphic content and unsettling themes. Its site showed $14 for the case and $67, on sale from $111, for a bundle of all eight and a bonus.
Cold Ledger cold cases are ours. There are four: The Orpheum File, Accident, Drink Involved, About Three, and No Letter This Year. The first three hold seventeen exhibits each and the fourth holds twelve. Each asks four questions you answer on the worksheet, with hints you can open one at a time and a sealed solution to check yourself against. They are for one or two people and one evening, 60 to 90 minutes, regularly $6.99 a case, as a PDF to print or in the browser, where two people can open the same file from a shared link. There are no props: it is documents, on paper or on a screen. See The Orpheum File.
CaseZero runs in the browser. You type your own questions to the suspects and make one final accusation. CaseZero says it uses AI for the suspects' replies, with a fixed solution for each case. You can start its first case, The Last Guest, free and without an account, with a limit on how many questions you can ask; three more cases come in a pack for €12.99.
PLAY INQUEST posts a free case every day that opens in a browser without an account. Signing in, also free, adds two-player co-op and more cases, and a paid Premium tier opens the longer archive. The developer says the daily case is generated each day and the separate Classified collection is hand-crafted.
A Longer Game for a Group
Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases. You use a map of London, a directory and newspapers to choose which leads to follow, then compare your investigation with Holmes's. The box lists at $59.99 and holds ten investigations for one to eight players, about $6 an investigation if you play them all.
How to Choose
For tonight, a download or a browser case. Ink & Clues sells PDFs, Masters of Mystery sells digital access, and CaseZero and PLAY INQUEST start free.
For a mailed evidence file, Unsolved Case Files, Death by Chef's Knife, Cryptic Killers or Deadbolt. If you want props as well as documents, check what comes in the specific box.
For a group that wants several full investigations, The Thames Murders & Other Cases has ten in one box.
For teenagers, check the age guidance for the case you plan to buy. Deadbolt recommends 13 and up, Unsolved Case Files and Death by Chef's Knife say 14 and up, and Ink & Clues recommends 18 and up for The Girl in the Snow.
Frequently asked questions
Can I buy a Hunt A Killer case without a subscription?
Yes. Hunt A Killer sells standalone cases, including Blood & Ink for $29.99. Its optional Evidence Locker membership renews at $50 a year, and the cases are still bought one at a time.
What can I play for free?
PLAY INQUEST offers a free case every day, and CaseZero's first full case is free.
Which of these can I play right away?
Anything that is a download or runs in a browser: Ink & Clues, Masters of Mystery's digital edition, CaseZero, PLAY INQUEST and our own cases above. The mailed files have to ship, unless a store near you has one on the shelf.
Which are made for two people?
Masters of Mystery's Edward Munst case is designed for one or two, and so are our own cases above. PLAY INQUEST has free two-player co-op with an account, and Hunt A Killer's Blood & Ink takes two within its one-to-six range.
Do any of these need the internet?
Several of the mailed ones do. Unsolved Case Files checks your answers online, Deadbolt uses QR codes to reach some clues, Cryptic Killers' Murder of a Millionaire uses an online police inbox, and Masters of Mystery uses a case portal even with the printed kit. The browser cases need a connection throughout. A PDF needs nothing once it is printed or saved.
Sources
Every figure above, from the maker's own listing or the retailer named, read on November 22, 2026:
- Hunt A Killer, Blood & Ink
- Hunt A Killer, Evidence Locker
- Unsolved Case Files, Harmony Ashcroft
- Unsolved Case Files, FAQ
- Unsolved Case Files, subscriptions
- Target, Unsolved Case Files: Harmony Ashcroft
- Amazon, Unsolved Case Files: Harmony Ashcroft
- University Games, Death by Chef's Knife
- Target, Death by Chef's Knife
- Deadbolt Mystery Society, one-time shop
- Deadbolt Mystery Society, month-to-month
- Cryptic Killers, Murder of a Millionaire
- Amazon, Cryptic Killers: Murder of a Millionaire
- Masters of Mystery, The Murder of Edward Munst (digital)
- Masters of Mystery, The Murder of Edward Munst (boxed)
- Ink & Clues, The Girl in the Snow
- Ink & Clues, home page (the bundle)
- CaseZero, case library
- CaseZero, AI disclosure
- CaseZero, terms
- PLAY INQUEST
- PLAY INQUEST, terms
- PLAY INQUEST, the Daily Dossier
- Space Cowboys, The Thames Murders
- Asmodee USA, The Thames Murders & Other Cases